core/ROADMAP-UI.md

# Armature — v0.6.x UI Hardening Roadmap

> **Goal**: Fix all viewport scaling, banner integration, and styling inconsistencies
> so Claude Code can run a meaningful automated usability survey against a
> stable, uniform UI.

---

## Problem Inventory

### P1 — Viewport & Scaling (blocks everything)

| # | Issue | Where | Impact |
|---|-------|-------|--------|
| 1 | **Dual layout systems** — `base.html` template has its own banner→surface→footer column; `app-shell.js` Preact shell has a separate `sw-shell` → `sw-shell__body` → `sw-shell__surface` column. They never coordinate. | `server/pages/templates/base.html` ↔ `src/js/sw/shell/app-shell.js` | Every surface inherits an ambiguous viewport ancestor. |
| 2 | **Transform-based scaling is broken** — `transform: scale()` on `#surfaceInner` doesn't reflow layout. Breaks `getBoundingClientRect` (menu.js already carries a scale-correction hack at line 20), scroll containment, pointer events, and the inverse-width/height hack (`100/s%`) doesn't account for banners consuming viewport space. | `base.html:56-67`, `appearance.js:41-53`, `menu.js:20-33` | Menus, tooltips, dropdowns all mis-positioned at any non-100% scale. Click targets wrong. |
| 3 | **Banner height desync** — `base.html` hardcodes `--banner-h: 28px` and renders banners in-flow. `app-shell.js` ShellBanner measures `offsetHeight` into `--banner-top-height` / `--banner-bottom-height` and uses `position: fixed` + body padding. Two independent banner systems. | `base.html:31,72-75,103-107` ↔ `app-shell.js:25-42`, `sw-shell.css:22-37,63-69` | With banners enabled, content overflows by the banner height or gets double-inset depending on which code path is active. |
| 4 | **`100vh` on mobile** — `.sw-shell`, `.chat-app`, `.chat-loading`, `.login-shell` use `100vh` which doesn't subtract mobile browser chrome (address bar, toolbar). | `sw-shell.css:9`, `chat/css/main.css:15,25`, `sw-login.css:7` | Content overflows on iOS Safari, Android Chrome. |
| 5 | **Chat uses `100vh` not `100%`** — `.chat-app { height: 100vh }` ignores parent container (which already excludes banners/footer). Notes correctly uses `height: 100%`. Every extension surface that copies chat's pattern will inherit the bug. | `packages/chat/css/main.css:15` | Chat surface overflows behind banners. |

### P2 — CSS Architecture

| # | Issue | Where | Impact |
|---|-------|-------|--------|
| 6 | **Class name collisions** — `.settings-section` defined in both `modals.css:41-43` and `surfaces.css:75-83` with different padding, margin, and border-bottom rules. `.sw-dropdown` in `primitives.css:443` (styled `<select>`) vs `sw-primitives.css:262` (custom dropdown component). `.sw-tabs` in `primitives.css:459` vs `sw-primitives.css:234`. | Kernel CSS | Styles randomly win depending on load order. Bug reports differ by surface. |
| 7 | **Old/new primitive duplication** — Two button systems (`.btn-primary`/`.btn-small` in `primitives.css` vs `.sw-btn--primary`/`.sw-btn--sm` in `sw-primitives.css`). Two toast systems (`.toast` vs `.sw-toast`). Two dropdown, two tabs implementations. | `primitives.css` ↔ `sw-primitives.css` | No single source of truth for any component. Extension authors can't know which to use. |
| 8 | **Extension CSS bleeds globally** — Extension `main.css` loaded via `<link>` at document level, no scoping. Any class name can override kernel or sibling extension styles. | `base.html:26-28`, `extension-surface.css` | Package CSS fights with kernel. Two packages with `.sidebar` both lose. |
| 9 | **No intermediate breakpoint** — Only `768px` mobile breakpoint. No tablet (768–1024px). Secondary workspace pane hardcoded `480px`. Admin nav hardcoded `200px`. | `layout.css:263`, `surfaces.css:305` | Cramped layout on iPad/small laptops. |

### P3 — Visual Consistency

| # | Issue | Where | Impact |
|---|-------|-------|--------|
| 10 | **Mixed unit systems** — `px`, `rem`, `em` used interchangeably with no rationale. Some font-sizes in `px` (primitives), others in `rem` (sw-primitives), others in `em` (user-picker). | All CSS files | Zoom/scale behaves differently per element. |
| 11 | **Google Fonts CDN dependency** — `@import url(...)` in `variables.css:5` blocks rendering if CDN is slow; breaks entirely on air-gapped deployments. | `variables.css:5` | FOUT or blank page on slow networks. No offline support. |
| 12 | **No spacing scale** — Padding/margins are ad-hoc values (10px, 12px, 14px, 16px, 20px, 24px, 28px…). No design-token spacing scale. | All CSS | Inconsistent visual rhythm across surfaces. |
| 13 | **Hardcoded fallback colors in component CSS** — `sw-shell.css`, `sw-primitives.css` have inline fallbacks like `var(--accent, #b38a4e)` — a gold color from a previous theme that doesn't match the current blue `#6c9fff`. | `sw-shell.css`, `sw-primitives.css` | Wrong colors flash briefly if variables load late. |

---

## Roadmap

### v0.6.9 — Session Lifetime Config ✅

Shipped. Admin-configurable TTLs, "keep me logged in" checkbox, idle timeout,
config-driven `generateTokens()`, 7 new tests. See CHANGELOG.md for details.

### v0.6.10 — Viewport Foundation ✅

Shipped. Single layout model: `body → shell → surface`. CSS `zoom` replaces
`transform: scale()`. `100dvh` fallbacks everywhere. Extension surfaces use
`100%` instead of `100vh`. Dead shell layout code deprecated. See CHANGELOG.md.

### v0.6.11 — CSS Deduplication ✅

Shipped. Old primitive system retired. One class per concept. See CHANGELOG.md.

| Step | Description |
|------|-------------|
| Audit collision inventory | Script that finds all duplicate class selectors across kernel CSS files. Produce a machine-readable collision report (JSON). |
| Migrate `.settings-section` | Remove `modals.css:41-43` definition. The `surfaces.css` definition is authoritative. Modals that used the old styles get explicit overrides scoped to `.modal .settings-section`. |
| Retire `primitives.css` old components | `.btn-primary`, `.btn-small`, `.btn-danger`, `.btn-full` → migrate all usages to `.sw-btn--*`. `.toast-container` / `.toast` → migrate to `.sw-toast-container` / `.sw-toast`. Old `.popup-menu` → migrate to `.sw-menu`. Old `.sw-dropdown` (styled select in primitives.css) → rename to `.sw-native-select` or delete if unused. Old `.sw-tabs` / `.sw-tab-btn` in primitives.css → delete (sw-primitives.css version is authoritative). |
| Mark deprecated classes | Any remaining old classes get a `/* DEPRECATED v0.6.11 — use .sw-btn--* */` comment and a 1-version grace period for package authors. |
| Package CSS audit | Scan all `packages/*/css/main.css` for references to deprecated kernel classes. Fix in-tree packages. |

### v0.6.12 — Extension CSS Isolation ✅

Shipped. Prefix enforcement via linter. All 12 in-tree packages migrated.
See CHANGELOG.md.

| Step | Description |
|------|-------------|
| Scoping strategy | Prefix enforcement (option B). `@scope` support still patchy; prefix works everywhere, trivially lintable. |
| Linter | `scripts/lint-package-css.sh` — validates first class selector in every rule starts with `.ext-{slug}`. Exempts `:root`, `@keyframes`, `@font-face`, `@media`, `.sw-*` kernel classes, `.cm-*` CodeMirror classes. |
| Kernel CSS contract | `docs/EXTENSION-CSS.md` — stable public classes (`.sw-btn--*`, `.sw-input`, `.sw-field`, `.sw-dialog`, `.sw-toast`, `.sw-menu`, `.sw-tabs`, etc.) and all CSS variables. Everything else internal. |
| Migrate in-tree packages | `data-ext="{{.Surface}}"` on extension mount. All 12 packages prefixed to `.ext-{slug}-*`. CSS + JS updated in lockstep. |

### v0.6.13 — Responsive & Spacing

Fill the gaps between mobile and desktop.

| Step | Description |
|------|-------------|
| Tablet breakpoint | Add `@media (min-width: 769px) and (max-width: 1024px)` rules. Secondary workspace pane: `360px` (from `480px`). Admin nav collapses to icon-only at this breakpoint. Settings nav: `180px`. |
| Spacing scale | Define spacing tokens in `variables.css`: `--space-1: 4px` through `--space-8: 64px` (4px base, doubling). Migrate hardcoded padding/margin values to tokens. Priority: surfaces that users see on every session (sidebar, topbar, admin content areas). |
| Font-size scale | Define `--text-xs: 0.75rem` through `--text-xl: 1.25rem` (5 stops). Migrate all font-size declarations. Remove `em`-based sizes (user-picker) and bare `px` sizes. |
| Secondary pane responsive | `workspace-secondary.open` width uses `clamp(320px, 35vw, 560px)` instead of fixed `480px`. |

### v0.6.14 — Visual Polish

Systematic cleanup of stale values and rendering artifacts.

| Step | Description |
|------|-------------|
| Purge stale fallback colors | Remove all `var(--foo, #hexvalue)` fallbacks that reference old gold theme colors (`#b38a4e` and variants). If a CSS variable is undefined at this point, that's a bug — don't mask it with a wrong fallback. |
| Self-host fonts | Bundle DM Sans and JetBrains Mono woff2 files in `src/fonts/`. Replace Google Fonts `@import` with local `@font-face` declarations. Zero external font dependencies. |
| Light theme audit | Walk every surface in light mode. Fix any remaining hardcoded dark-mode colors, contrast issues, or invisible borders. Document any surface-specific light-mode overrides. |
| Consistent border-radius | Surfaces currently mix `6px`, `8px`, `10px`, `var(--radius)`, `var(--radius-lg)`. Audit and reduce to 3 values: `--radius-sm: 4px`, `--radius: 8px`, `--radius-lg: 12px`. |

### v0.6.15 — Usability Survey Gate

Make the UI machine-auditable so Claude Code can run an automated survey.

| Step | Description |
|------|-------------|
| UI inventory manifest | `scripts/generate-ui-inventory.sh` — walks kernel CSS + package CSS, extracts every rendered class, groups by surface, outputs `ui-inventory.json`. Fields: `{surface, component, classes, file, line, responsive_breakpoints, spacing_tokens_used, font_size_tokens_used}`. |
| Contrast checker | Script that parses `variables.css` light/dark token pairs and checks WCAG AA contrast ratios for all `text-*` on `bg-*` combinations. Outputs pass/fail report. |
| Component coverage matrix | Markdown table: each kernel primitive (button, input, dropdown, dialog, toast, menu, tabs, avatar, spinner, tooltip, drawer, banner) × each surface that uses it. Identifies surfaces still using deprecated old-style components. |
| Touch target audit | Script that finds all `<button>`, `[role=button]`, clickable elements across templates and JS, checks for `min-width/min-height ≥ 44px` on mobile breakpoint. |
| Claude Code survey prompt | `docs/USABILITY-SURVEY.md` — structured prompt template that Claude Code can execute against the codebase. Sections: viewport correctness, banner integration, responsive behavior, styling consistency, accessibility basics (contrast, touch targets, focus indicators), component uniformity. Each section has pass/fail criteria and file paths to inspect. |
| Survey dry-run | Run the survey. Fix anything it catches. Tag `v0.6.15` only after clean survey. |

---

## Sequencing Rationale

```
v0.6.9  Session Lifetime Config ✅ SHIPPED
  ↓
v0.6.10 Viewport Foundation     ✅ SHIPPED
  ↓
v0.6.11 CSS Deduplication       ✅ SHIPPED
  ↓
v0.6.12 Extension CSS Isolation ✅ SHIPPED
  ↓
v0.6.13 Responsive & Spacing    ← Spacing tokens need stable class names to attach to
  ↓
v0.6.14 Visual Polish           ← Final visual pass after structure is locked
  ↓
v0.6.15 Usability Survey Gate   ← Machine-audit the finished product
```

Each version is independently shippable and testable. No version depends on
anything after it.

---

## What "Usability Survey by Code" Means

The v0.6.15 deliverables give Claude Code (or any automated tool) three things:

1. **A structured inventory** (`ui-inventory.json`) of every component, on every
   surface, with its CSS file and line number.

2. **Automated checks** (contrast, touch targets, token usage) that produce
   machine-readable pass/fail reports.

3. **A survey prompt** (`USABILITY-SURVEY.md`) with explicit criteria and file
   paths, so Claude Code can `cat` the relevant files, run the scripts, and
   produce a scored report without human guidance.

The survey is not a substitute for real user testing — it's a structural
quality gate that catches the class of bugs (overflow, contrast, misalignment,
inconsistent styling) that have historically slipped through.